Chef's Challenge: Grumpfin

Objectives
Bring back Grumpfin's Eye
 * Grumpfin's Eye

Description
There's a fish here that's eluded me for years. He lives at the bottom of the largest lake, and we've named him Grumpfin for his personality. I think it's time to catch him and cook him! Bring him to me, but be careful - he's an ornery old devil.

Rewards
You will receive:
 * 12,870 XP
 * 12,870 XP