Crudely Wrapped Gift

A Crudely Wrapped Gift is a quest reward for the Smash the Pumpkin (Alliance) and Smash the Pumpkin (Horde) daily quests. It contains random loot from the Hallow's End seasonal event.

Source
During Hallow's End, you can battle the in villages around the world of Azeroth, then loot his large pumpkin head for a Scorched Holy Symbol quest item and turn it in to the  for the Smash the Pumpkin daily quests. She rewards you with a Crudely Wrapped Gift containing event goodies.

Contains
The Crudely Wrapped Gift can contain multiple items.

Primarily
Getting all four of these is not rare.
 * 3-5 Weighted Jack-o'-Lantern
 * Handful of Treats
 * Magic Broom
 * Folded Letter

May also contain
You can get more than one of these.
 * Sinister Squashling
 * Hallowed Helm
 * Hallowed Wand - Bat
 * Hallowed Wand - Ghost
 * Hallowed Wand - Leper Gnome
 * Hallowed Wand - Ninja
 * Hallowed Wand - Pirate
 * Hallowed Wand - Skeleton
 * Hallowed Wand - Wisp
 * Blood Elf Female Mask
 * Draenei Female Mask
 * Dwarf Female Mask
 * Gnome Female Mask
 * Human Female Mask
 * Night Elf Female Mask
 * Orc Female Mask
 * Tauren Female Mask
 * Troll Female Mask
 * Undead Female Mask
 * Blood Elf Male Mask
 * Draenei Male Mask
 * Dwarf Male Mask
 * Gnome Male Mask
 * Human Male Mask
 * Night Elf Male Mask
 * Orc Male Mask
 * Tauren Male Mask
 * Troll Male Mask
 * Undead Male Mask

Removed
These were common in 2008, but appear to have been removed from the loot table for the Crudely Wrapped Gift for 2009.

These candies can still be contained in the Treat Bags obtained by Trick or Treating at the inns.
 * Candy Bar (Hallow's End) 11-61%
 * Lollipop (Hallow's End) 13-70.8%
 * Candy Corn 13-67.6%

These appear to no longer be obtainable from either source.
 * Hallowed Wand - Random 14.9-16%