Retribution (quest)

Objectives
Kill The Unforgiven and Timmy the Cruel.
 * The Unforgiven slain
 * Timmy the Cruel slain

Description
Where Market Row meets Festival Lane, you will encounter The Unforgiven. If you slay the entirety of Crusaders' Square, you will coax out Timmy the Cruel. Both of these former champions committed heinous acts against innocents here in the name of gaining unholy power.

You must destroy both of them and rid Stratholme of their foul presence. Take caution, for they were powerful fighters in life, and their new dark powers will only have made them even more deadly.

Rewards
You will receive:

Progress
...

Completion
You may have this as a suitable reward. I found it nestled in the armor of one of the scourge here.